Printable Version of Topic

Posted by: GA Secretary Mon, 13 Dec 2004 9:53 am

Hi, all comments are welcome on this ryukin.

Ryukin #1

Posted by: CP Mon, 13 Dec 2004 12:05 pm

Why so many ryukins these days?
IMO this is better than GA 66, but still way to go compared to Voids' avatar.
Plus points - Good lenght to height ratio, almost 1:1,partly because of the very short tail.And very good colouration.
As mentioned in my previous comments,I always look for a head that wedges into the hump,which this fish lacks.The ideal hump should should turn down from the dorsal fin and then move away from the head,as if the fish has just swam into a wall (long pia) and the head lodged into it as a result.
The tail is also set too low,mid point of tail at eye level.If you see Voids' avatar,the lower part of the tail is at eye level.

The above comments are not based on any standards,just my preference.


Regards
cpiw2002

Posted by: GA Secretary Mon, 13 Dec 2004 12:30 pm

So, based on what you said, in your opinion, are these two fishes better compared to the red one ?

Ryukin #2

Ryukin #3

Posted by: Frankie Mon, 13 Dec 2004 12:39 pm

I think they are all nice. But among them, i like the second one (with a red/white head) best. It looks most balanced (body/finages). The tails also opens up nicely.

I wish the side profile of the head is kinked (instead of relatively flat), like this Ryukin belonging to bro void.

Posted by: CP Mon, 13 Dec 2004 3:55 pm

So, based on what you said, in your opinion, are these two fishes better compared to the red one ?

Ryukin #2

Ryukin #3

Posted by: Frankie Mon, 13 Dec 2004 6:37 pm

Why so many ryukins these days?
IMO this is better than GA 66, but still way to go compared to Voids' avatar.
Plus points - Good lenght to height ratio, almost 1:1,partly because of the very short tail.And very good colouration.
As mentioned in my previous comments,I always look for a head that wedges into the hump,which this fish lacks.The ideal hump should should turn down from the dorsal fin and then move away from the head,as if the fish has just swam into a wall (long pia) and the head lodged into it as a result.
The tail is also set too low,mid point of tail at eye level.If you see Voids' avatar,the lower part of the tail is at eye level.

The above comments are not based on any standards,just my preference.
Regards
cpiw2002

Posted by: Frankie Thu, 16 Dec 2004 1:31 pm

wah lau, GA66 still young la, how to compare, wait a few months then compare again
anyway ga66 is better than all 3 ryukins posted in this thread